My canadian business

From Canadian Business Online Blog, Nov 02, 2009

 By: Larry MacDonald

Despite making an average $500,000 a year (in today’s prices), the great novelist and playwright F. Scott Fitzgerald, never was able to put money aside. He and his wife thought the solution was to budget, to prepare a complete record of what they had spent running the household. But somehow, at the end of the month, they were always over budget. There was continual “leakage,” leaving Fitzgerald and Zelda bewildered: “Somehow a mysterious third of our income had vanished into thin air,” wrote Fitzgerald.

A good financial planner or book on personal finances could have set them straight. Roy Miller, the wealthy barber in David Chilton’s classic book, initially had the same problem. “There was nothing left at the end of the month …. I had tried budgeting and it hadn’t worked,” he tells David, Tom and Cathy.

Then old Mr. White told the barber: “Pay yourself first.” That is, have 10% taken off your paycheck and put into a bank account or investment fund before you get your hands on it. Budgeting may work for a business because the owner wants to keep costs down but budgeting for a person is hard because wants tend to evolve into needs.”

You won’t notice it, the wealthy barber says of the automatic deduction: “I never did miss that money. My lifestyle didn’t change at all.”

More on this topic (What's this?)
Four Tips For Dealing With Budget Problems
Read more on Personal Budget at Wikinvest

Tags:   · ·

  1. 6 Responses to “ Budgeting vs. Paying Yourself First ”

  2. This approach should work for someone who has found that budgeting and accurately tracking expenses still leaves them empty handed.

    However, as mentioned in the blog, the problem is including wants in the budget as needs. This is also a serious problem.

    Somebody who perpetually “budgets” up their entire income and is forced to treat savings like a bill is applying a band-aid.

    It might work as a forced savings plan, but clearly issues regarding identifying needs and wants still needs addressing.

    By Steve on Nov 2, 2009

  3. Steve
    Yes, if one can keep wants from becoming needs, budgeting would work for sure.

    By Larry MacDonald on Nov 2, 2009

  4. As seniors on a fixed income, regular monthly savings provide a safety valve for the unexpected. Winter vacations can also be factored in if monies are available.

    By Murray on Nov 3, 2009

  5. Argh! Credit cards are officially evil! These tips helped save me from their tyranny: http://tinyurl.com/yfmy6bw

    By Emil on Nov 3, 2009

  1. 2 Trackback(s)

  2. Nov 3, 2009 : Daily Dimes 11/3/09 « Living With Common Cents
  3. Nov 6, 2009 : Canadian Personal Finance Blog » Blog Archive » Random Thoughts: Flip, Flop and Flu

Post a Comment

By posting your comment you agree to Canadian Business Online's Terms of Use.